When is New Investment Not Old Money?

Every winter brings announcements of additional funding designed to support the NHS through its busiest months. This year, attention has focused on a £40 million scheme intended to help General Practice identify and support vulnerable patients at risk of hospital admission during the winter period.

Any opinions stated here are those of the author and not of FPM or any affiliated company. 

This year, attention has focused on a £40 million scheme intended to help General Practice identify and support vulnerable patients at risk of hospital admission during the winter period.

On the surface, this sounds like good news. Few people would argue against helping frail and vulnerable patients remain well, avoid unnecessary hospital stays and receive care closer to home.

Yet behind the headlines lies a question that deserves closer examination:

Is this genuinely new investment in General Practice, or money that has already been taken away and is now being returned under a different name?

Recent concerns raised within Primary Care suggest that extensive patient list cleansing exercises have resulted in significant numbers of patients being removed from GP practice lists.

Maintaining accurate patient records is important and has always been a shared responsibility between practices and the NHS. However, many practices report that this year's exercise has been conducted more aggressively than in previous years, leading to substantial reductions in registered patient numbers and, consequently, reductions in practice income.

Some patient removals will undoubtedly be appropriate. Others remain disputed, with practices spending considerable time and resources identifying and reinstating patients who should not have been removed. Whatever the final figures ultimately show, the process has already had financial consequences because core funding is closely linked to the number of patients registered with a practice.

If that assessment is correct, the situation becomes difficult to ignore.

Practices first lose part of their core funding through reductions in patient list numbers. They are then offered access to a £40 million winter initiative that requires additional work, additional monitoring and additional responsibilities. The funding is presented publicly as new support for General Practice, yet many working within the sector question whether it is genuinely new investment or simply the partial return of money already removed from frontline services.

For patients, this may appear to be an internal NHS funding dispute. In reality, it goes to the heart of how healthcare services are sustained.

Why Core Funding Matters

Patients rarely take an interest in NHS funding formulas, and understandably so.

Most simply expect that when they contact their GP practice there will be enough staff to answer the telephone, enough clinicians to provide appointments and enough financial stability to keep services running effectively.

Core funding provides the foundation upon which those expectations rest.

It pays for staff salaries, premises, administration and the day-to-day operation of practices. It allows practices to plan ahead, recruit staff and invest in improving services.

Most importantly, it provides certainty.

Without that certainty, even well-intentioned initiatives can create additional pressure.

A practice cannot run its finances in the same way it runs a short-term project. One supports the ongoing delivery of care. The other comes and goes as schemes are introduced and withdrawn.

The Difference Between Funding and Investment

There is an important distinction between funding and investment.

Funding can simply move money from one place to another.

Investment should increase the overall capacity of a service.

Patients hearing about a £40 million announcement are likely to assume that additional money is entering General Practice. If, however, practices have already lost a comparable amount of income through reductions to patient lists and core allocations, then the announcement looks very different.

One might reasonably ask whether this is investment at all, or simply the redistribution of money already removed from the system.

Moreover, access to the new funding appears to depend upon practices undertaking additional work to identify, monitor and support high-risk patients throughout the winter.

Supporting vulnerable patients is undoubtedly worthwhile. Most GPs would regard this as a fundamental part of their role.

The concern is that practices may be asked to do more with resources that have effectively already been reduced.

The Bigger Picture

This debate extends beyond a single winter scheme.

The NHS is increasingly moving towards neighbourhood working, integrated care and prevention-focused services. These ambitions are sensible and widely supported.

However, such models depend upon strong and financially stable General Practice.

If funding gradually shifts away from core budgets and into a growing number of targeted schemes, there is a risk that practices become less stable and more dependent upon temporary initiatives.

Healthcare organisations need innovation. But they also need certainty.

A sustainable service requires both. There is also a question of trust.

When policymakers announce, "new investment", the public naturally assumes that additional resources are being put into patient care. If funding is first removed from the core budgets on which practices rely and then reappears through short-term schemes with additional conditions attached, many will question whether the description matches the reality.

Transparency matters, particularly when public confidence in primary care is already under pressure.

The Question We Should Ask

The issue here is not whether vulnerable patients deserve additional support.

They clearly do.

Nor is it whether preventing unnecessary hospital admissions is a worthwhile objective.

It undoubtedly is.

The real question is whether the NHS is strengthening the foundations of General Practice or simply moving money around the system while expecting practices to take on additional responsibilities.

When patients hear about "new investment", they naturally assume that additional resources are reaching frontline services. If practices have first lost income through list cleansing exercises and are then expected to undertake more work to recover some of that funding, that assumption deserves careful scrutiny.

Perhaps the question we should ask whenever a funding announcement is made is not:

"How much money has been announced?"

But rather:

"How much of it is genuinely new, and how much simply comes with new conditions attached?"

Patients do not experience NHS funding formulas, contractual mechanisms or headline announcements.

They experience whether they can get an appointment, whether their local surgery can recruit and retain staff, and whether General Practice remains sustainable for the future.

Ultimately, that is the measure by which every funding announcement should be judged.

Sources and Further Reading

  • Pulse Today reporting on the £40 million winter scheme for GP practices and Primary Care Networks.
  • NHS England winter resilience and admission avoidance initiatives.
  • Commentary from primary care leaders,  regarding the relationship between patient list cleansing, reductions in core practice income and the new funding announcement.
  • NHS General Medical Services (GMS) funding arrangements and global sum methodology.

Note: This article reflects concerns expressed by commentators within General Practice regarding the impact of patient list cleansing and the presentation of winter funding announcements. NHS England's position is that the funding is intended to support vulnerable patients and reduce avoidable hospital admissions over winter. Readers may wish to consider both perspectives when forming their own conclusions.

Created by Primary Care Correspondent
Primary Care Correspondent
An anonymous author and sector expert who gives their views on the latest happenings in primary care and the wider healthcare sector. Please note that any views or opinions expressed by the Primary Care Correspondent are independent to those of FPM and do not reflect the views or position of FPM Group, Thornfields or Stericycle.

0 Comments

Leave a Comment

Your comment